back to top

A Step-by-Step Guide on How To Choose The Best Membership Model

Published
March 1, 2024

What’s a Rich Text element?

The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

Crowdfundly Opengraph image

Static and dynamic content editing

Hi. I’m Seth Godin. I’m a teacher, and I do projects. For more than thirty years, I’ve been trying to turn on lights, inspire people and teach them how to level up – Seth Godin

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

A list looks like this:

  • Marketing Is about The Stories You Tell
  • Do Permission Marketing
  • Invent, Implement and Sell the Ideas
  • Sell What People Want, Not What They Need
  • Keep Your Customers Happy
  • Deliver Basic Human Wants

A list looks like this:

  1. Marketing Is about The Stories You Tell
  2. Marketing Is about The Stories You Tell
  3. Marketing Is about The Stories You Tell
  4. Marketing Is about The Stories You Tell
  5. Marketing Is about The Stories You Tell
  6. Marketing Is about The Stories You Tell

Choosing the right membership model is vital for growth and sustainability. This comprehensive guide outlines six steps to guide your decision-making process:

  • Member Analysis: Assess member needs.
  • Membership Model: Choose flat rates or tiered models based on goals.
  • Dues Structure: Set values, benchmark against peers.
  • Brand Your Program: Get creative with names and tiers.
  • Transparent Communication: Clearly explain changes and benefits.
  • Marketing Blitz: Launch with a social media blitz.

To make your decision easier, the steps to choose the best membership model are further detailed and elaborated in the article ahead.

the steps to choose the best membership model

What Is A Membership Model?

A membership model is a structured business plan wherein individuals pay recurring fees to access an organization's value. It dictates membership levels, revenue sources, marketing, events, and finances. 

Examples include clubs, professional associations, nonprofits, and businesses like Amazon Prime. It boosts engagement, retention, event attendance, and revenue growth. The model often features tiers with higher dues offering additional benefits. 

This strategy, common in businesses like gyms and online platforms, ensures a steady income stream, usually through monthly or yearly payments. A membership site is integral, providing controlled access to content. 

The model's success lies in formalizing procedures and tailoring them to the product or service offered.

Benefits You Get For Using A Membership Model

Benefits of using a membership model for your organization are-

  • Boost Revenue: Create upsells for added benefits, increasing income.
  • Attract New Members: Craft unique offerings for different tiers to draw diverse memberships.
  • Increase Satisfaction: Flexible options enhance member satisfaction and retention.
  • Access Valuable Data: Segmenting members based on levels provides valuable data insights.
  • Additional Benefits: Stable Cash Flow: Monthly dues ensure predictable cash flow.
  • Lower Marketing Costs: Reduced expenses after acquiring new members.
  • Lower Business Costs: Scalable value creation lowers production costs.
  • Direct Feedback: Quick recognition of service issues through member engagement.
  • Community Impact: Membership managers uplift entire communities through valuable resources.
  • Exclusive Data Access: Track member behavior for informed decision-making.
  • Diverse Revenue Streams: Merchandise sales, events, and sponsorships beyond dues.
  • Predictable Income: Steady recurring revenue aids budgeting and planning.
  • Customer Retention: Encourages long-term engagement, boosting customer lifetime value.
  • Relationship Building: Establish stronger, longer-term relationships with customers.
  • Upselling Opportunities: More chances to offer additional services, enhancing revenue potential.
  • Stability: Commitment periods provide stability amid market fluctuations.
  • Community Building: Foster a sense of community for increased loyalty and referrals.
  • Customer Insights: Regular interactions yield valuable data for strategic decisions.
  • Cost-Effective Growth: Lower customer acquisition costs compared to new customers.
  • Perceived Value: Customers feel they receive better value, enhancing satisfaction and loyalty.

Success depends on consistently delivering value to members, ensuring continued attractiveness and value perception.

Types Of Membership Models

Since you know the benefits now, find out the details about all the types of model you can choose from- 

All-Access Model

Instant access to all resources, products, or offerings with a flat fee or monthly payment.

Advantage: Attracts a larger customer base with an enticing offer.

Consideration: Risk of short-term subscriptions; use platforms like MemberSpace for easy implementation.

Drip Model

Content or resources released gradually with regular payments, keeping members engaged. Ideal for monthly fee structures; use platforms like MemberSpace for automated content dripping.

Community Model

Members pay for access to an exclusive online community with forums and networking. Ideal fo sites with a loyal following and specialized interests; use platforms like MemberSpace and Circle for easy setup.

Timed Model

Offers a fixed-length membership with an expiration date.

Benefit: More sign-ups due to less commitment.

Implementation: Use platforms like MemberSpace for automatic plan expiration.

Course Model

Memberships tailored around online courses, with options for drip, all-access, or fixed time.

Consideration: Choose the model based on content delivery preferences; use platforms like MemberSpace for flexibility.

Product or Service Model

Offers a specific product or service through the membership model.

Example: Upselling additional products or services for recurring revenue.

Implementation: Platforms like MemberSpace suit businesses offering tools, coaching, or remote services.

Combo Model

Creatively combines different membership formats.

Example: Drip fresh content to a community-style platform or upsell fixed membership with access to a resource library.

Consideration: Tailor the combo to your unique vision; use platforms like MemberSpace for versatile integration.

Flat Rate Model

All members pay the same rate for the same benefits.

Pros: Simplifies member dues management.

Cons: Limited revenue opportunities and potential alienation of price-sensitive members.

Tiered Levels Model

Membership packages with different levels of benefits based on value, career stage, or donation.

Pros: Tailored benefits increase engagement and retention.

Cons: Pricing complexity; requires effective communication; use platforms like MemberSpace for organized member management.

Freemium Model

Offers basic services for free, with advanced features requiring a paid subscription.

Example: Slack offers limited features for free, unlocking more with a premium subscription.

Implementation: Use platforms like MemberSpace for effective freemium membership management.

Challenges & Accountability Groups

Motivates members to achieve goals through regular challenges and accountability groups.

Example: Habitica turns accountability into a game for goal achievement.

Recommendation: Incorporate gamification features; use platforms like MemberSpace for community management.

Software Model

SaaS-based membership model with recurring subscriptions.

Example: Basecamp provides an all-in-one project management solution with a subscription.

Benefit: Scalability and high perceived value; use platforms like MemberSpace for secure access.

All-In-One Membership Model

Single, recurring fee for access to a suite of products or services.

Example: Combines various offerings under one umbrella for convenience.

Advantage: Simplifies access and offers comprehensive value; use platforms like MemberSpace for integrated membership management.

Choose the membership model that aligns with your content, goals, and audience preferences. Platforms like MemberSpace can streamline the implementation process, ensuring smooth and efficient membership management.

Factors To Consider When Choosing A Membership Model

Choosing the right membership model can make a world of difference in the success of your venture. Let's dive into some key considerations before that first:

Tailor Your Model to Your Content

Consider the type of content you offer. Whether it's a fitness program, physical products, or coaching services, your model should align with the nature of your offerings. For example, a fitness program might thrive on a monthly access fee, providing new content regularly to keep members engaged.

Align with Your Goals

What are your goals for the site? Whether you're aiming for a side income or building a six-figure business, your membership model should reflect these aspirations. Scalability is key – think about a metered billing model if you provide services, allowing you to raise rates as your reputation grows.

Time Management is Crucial

Realistically assess how much time you can devote to your site. If time is limited, a drip content model can be a lifesaver. Scheduled content releases over time require less immediate attention, ensuring your subscribers don't feel shortchanged.

Understand Your Audience

Consider your audience's preferences. Providing flexibility in accessing content can be a game-changer. Offering various pricing tiers or an all-access pass can cater to different customer needs. Always keep your audience in mind to maximize profits.

What Do Your Members Want From You?

Your members are the heartbeat of your membership site, and meeting their needs is paramount. Consider these factors when shaping your model:

Meet Customer Needs

Your membership model should align with what your customers are seeking. Whether it's resources for entrepreneurs, fitness coaching, or exclusive discounts, ensure your offerings meet their needs.

Offer Convenience

A convenient membership model attracts and retains customers. Make sure your site is easily accessible and user-friendly, adding value to your customers' experience.

Maintain Consistency

Your membership model should align with your brand. Consistency in messaging, products, and services reinforces your image and builds trust among your members.

Guide To Choose The Right Membership Model

Choosing the right membership model here is the awaited and the most critical step in ensuring growth and sustainability. Let's explore this guide with 6 Steps for Choosing the Right Membership Model to help you make the best decision for your organization. 

1. Analyze Your Member Audience

Understanding your existing members is the first crucial step. Conduct member needs assessments to gather real-time data. Ask questions like why they joined, current benefits, and any additional features they wish to see. This insight will guide your model selection.

2. Choose Your Membership Model

Select a membership model aligned with your organization's goals. For clubs, a straightforward flat rate might suffice, while associations with diverse backgrounds may benefit from a tiered model. Ensure that higher tiers offer distinct value to incentivize members.

3. Determine Your Dues Structure

Once your model is chosen, attach monetary values to each membership level. Benchmark against similar organizations in your field to stay competitive. Your dues structure should reflect the perceived value of each membership tier.

4. Brand Your Membership Program

Inject creativity into your membership tiers by giving them descriptive names. For example, a culinary association might have tiers like Executive Chef, Head Chef, Sous Chef, and Junior Chef. Use colors or precious metals to add distinction. Clearly outline benefits, dues, and term length on your website.

5. Communicate Changes Transparently

If implementing a new model or altering existing tiers, transparency is key. Communicate why the change is happening, how it benefits members, when it takes effect, and whom to contact for questions. Keep your members in the loop to maintain trust.

6. Market Your New Membership Model

Launch your new model with a marketing blitz. Leverage social media, email newsletters, and your website to share stories, graphics, and tidbits highlighting the benefits of the change. Engage both current and potential members to ensure a smooth transition.

You can now create your own membership site as well with the help of few tips.

Choose The Right Membership Management Tool 

Choosing the right membership management tool is a crucial decision for the success of your organization. In this context, let's explore how Crowdfundly can be the ideal choice for managing memberships and enhancing your crowdfunding efforts.

Choose The Right Membership Management Tool 

Why Crowdfundly as Your Membership Management Tool?

Seamless Integration

Crowdfundly seamlessly integrates with various platforms, making it easy to incorporate into your existing systems. Integration with your website, social media, and other tools ensures a smooth and unified experience for both you and your members.

Membership and Crowdfunding in One Platform

Crowdfundly offers a comprehensive solution by combining membership management and crowdfunding features in a single platform. Manage your member database efficiently while running crowdfunding campaigns seamlessly, streamlining your operations.

User-Friendly Interface

Crowdfundly is designed with a user-friendly interface, ensuring ease of use for both administrators and members. Intuitive navigation and clear features make it convenient to manage memberships, launch campaigns, and engage with your community.

Customizable Membership Tiers

Tailor membership tiers to fit your organization's needs. Crowdfundly allows you to create and customize tiers based on benefits, pricing, and access levels. Adjust membership structures as needed, offering flexibility to accommodate different member preferences.

Transparent Communication

Effective communication is key. Crowdfundly provides tools for transparent communication with your members. Keep members informed about changes, updates, and ongoing crowdfunding campaigns through automated messages, notifications, and newsletters.

Integrated Crowdfunding Campaigns

Capitalize on Crowdfundly's crowdfunding features to raise funds for your organization or specific projects. Engage members in the fundraising process, turning them into active participants in the growth and success of your organization.

How to Implement Crowdfundly as Your Membership Management Tool:

By incorporating Crowdfundly as your membership management tool, you not only streamline your operations but also empower your organization to thrive in both membership engagement and fundraising endeavors.

The Major Downside Of Membership Models

While membership models offer numerous benefits for businesses, it's crucial to acknowledge the downsides. Understanding these challenges is essential for effectively navigating the complexities of membership-based organizations. 

Here are some significant downsides to consider:

Content Debt

Membership creators may find themselves in "content debt" when committing to providing a specific amount of new content regularly. For instance, promising a new course every month can be challenging without a clear plan for content creation. This pressure to consistently deliver fresh content can be overwhelming for creators and impact the overall sustainability of the membership model.

Churn

Customer churn, the decision of members to cancel their subscriptions, is a prevalent challenge in membership models. If members perceive that there's no new value or content for them, they might opt to cancel their memberships. 

Strategies can be employed to reduce churn, but understanding that some level of customer turnover is inevitable is crucial.

Marketing Funnel

A continuous challenge for membership models is the need to add new leads to the marketing funnel consistently. Due to the natural churn of members, businesses must constantly attract new prospects to replace those leaving. While membership models excel in marketing and selling, maintaining a steady influx of new leads is a perpetual requirement.

Added Customer Service

Membership models, serving a larger audience than one-to-one business models, generate an increased volume of customer service requests. The scalability of a membership model can lead to a higher demand for customer support, requiring businesses to be prepared for added service responsibilities. 

Even the most successful businesses should anticipate a rise in customer service demands when adopting a membership model. It's essential to emphasize that while these downsides pose challenges, they should not necessarily deter businesses from implementing a membership model. 

Instead, a strategic approach, proactive planning, and continuous adaptation can help mitigate these issues and ensure the sustained success of the membership-based organization.

FAQs

What Makes A Good Membership?

Great memberships are perpetual works-in-progress, evolving based on active member feedback and market developments. Sustaining relevance ensures long-term value and community indispensability.

How Do You Build A Successful Membership?

Build a successful membership by choosing a vital topic, defining an ideal member, crafting a purpose statement, selecting a platform, designing experiences, setting prices, executing marketing, recruiting, hosting events, maintaining consistency, and prioritizing continuous learning.

What Are The Models Of Membership Clubs?

The four common types are trade associations, members-as-donors, members-as-consumers, and members-as-advocates. Choose based on your organization's structure, purpose, and target audience.

What Is A Membership Strategy?

A membership strategy involves consistent, ongoing efforts to engage members. Deliver continuous value, adjust plans as needed, and prioritize consistent action to foster member engagement and long-term success.

Crowdfundly Team
The Crowdfundly team gathers to write up actionable resources to help you start, create, publish, and promote your content on Crowdfundly.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get monthly art tips, expert advice, and creator community insights delivered to your inbox. Subscribe now!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
back to top
Purple sky background with crescent moon

Boost Your Creative Journey with Crowdfundly Newsletter

Found this content helpful? Get freshly baked tips, expert advice, and the creator's success story delivered to your inbox every month and boost your creative business. Subscribe now!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.